Guides
November 30, 2022

How To Use A Butt Plug

Using a butt plug can make anal play even more pleasurable.
Written by
Sarah duRivage-Jacobs
Published on
November 30, 2022
Updated on
What's changed?
When you purchase a pleasure product from O.school, we donate to support sexual health organizations. Shop now at O.shop.

Butt plugs are an incredibly common sex toy that do double-duty: They can feel immensely pleasurable and be used as an anal training tool to help you eventually size up to a larger anal toy or penis. Whether butt plugs are a stop on the path to something else or a destination all on their own, here’s what you need to know about how to use this type of butt toy properly. 

Editor’s pick for getting started with butt plugs

B-Vibe Novice Plug
B-Vibe Novice Plug Hand
B-Vibe Novice Plug Charger
B-Vibe Novice Plug Packaging
B-Vibe Novice Plug Box

Well-suited for beginners, b-Vibe’s Novice Plug is a remote-controlled anal plug designed with smooth silicone and a classic tapered shape. It offers double penetration, and you can wear it during solo or partner play. The Novice Plug is also great for travel — it features a travel lock, a storage case, and it’s petite enough to fit in a small bag.

Benefits
Good for beginners
Built-in travel lock
Comes with a durable storage case
Comes with a remote control
Drawbacks
Might not be strong enough for more experienced users
Not waterproof, only splashproof
The nuts and bolts
  • 15 vibration patterns
  • 6 intensity levels
  • Splashproof
  • USB rechargeable
  • Magnetic, labeled cable
  • Body-safe materials: silicone
  • 3.4 x 1 in

How to use a butt plug

Learning how to use a butt plug properly can make the experience more pleasurable, whether you’re playing alone or with a partner. Here are some steps to follow to get you started. 

1. Choose a butt plug that’s right for you

There are plenty of butt plugs out there that can stimulate you in different ways, or help you graduate to a bigger butt plug in the future. To choose a butt plug that’s right for you, consider such factors as material, weight, size, price, if you want vibration, if you’re a beginner or an advanced user, etc. Ask yourself if you’re using the toy for solo, partnered play, or both. Are you incorporating it into foreplay, is it the main event, or are you using it to add some kink? Considering these things can help you narrow down the options. 

2. Opt for a plug with a flared base

A butt plug with a flared base will be easier to control with a hand and keep the plug from getting stuck. You or a partner can grasp the plug by its base to tease the anus and then guide it in (and pull it out) at whatever pace and depth feels good. 

3. Lube up the plug

Unlike the vagina, there’s no natural lubrication in the anus and rectum. That’s why lube is a must for any butt toy, plugs included. Silicon lube is especially good for anal play because it’s thick enough for easy gliding in and out — and it’ll typically last longer than a water-based lube (which is often recommended for use with sex toys because of universal material compatibility).

We recommend: Jo H20 Anal Lubricant

4. Relax your body for easier insertion

Relaxation is an especially critical aspect of using butt plugs. The rectum has two sphincters: an external sphincter, which is what a toy first passes through, and an internal sphincter. The internal sphincter doesn’t contract voluntarily, so it needs a little encouragement to open up. Massage with scented oil, masturbation, or oral sex can help loosen you up enough to welcome the plug in.

5. Try a finger before the plug

When using a butt plug for the first time, the smaller, the better. Start by very slowly circling the anus and then sticking one lubed-up finger into the rectum. You can move your finger around to slowly stretch the edges of the anus and tease it for something larger.

6. Trace the rim around the anus before going inside

Use the plug to slowly and lightly trace the anal rim. Doing this before inserting the plug can help with relaxing the muscles and priming the anus for what’s coming next.

7. Go slow when putting the butt plug in

As with any anal toy, take it slow and steady. Apply light pressure while wiggling and guiding the butt plug in and out of your anus. The plug can be inserted all the way to the flared base, but only go as deep as is comfortable.

8. Lean into the plug

Pressing yourself against the plug once it’s inside will help you find the exact angle and pressure that feels the best. It can also help with putting more direct contact on the prostate or against a penis or toy in the vagina.

9. Keep butt plugs clean

All pleasure products should be cleaned before, after, and between uses to maintain good hygiene and toy shelf life. When choosing a butt plug, opt for non-porous materials (e.g., silicon, glass) for the easiest maintenance.

We recommend: Pjur Med Clean Spray

10. Ease your way into bigger plugs (if you want to)

Larger butt plugs equal a fuller feeling, which is a main draw for a lot of people who use them. After starting small, you can introduce successively larger plugs until you reach the size you desire — or feel ready for a larger anal toy or penetration with a penis. Training kits, like this one from B-Vibe, include a range of plug sizes to get you started.

We recommend: B-Vibe Anal Training Education Set 

5 tips to maximize pleasure with a butt plug

Once you’ve gotten the basics of butt plugs down, the following recommendations can help you take your experience to the next level.

1. Try dual stimulation while wearing the plug

Simultaneous stimulation of the genitals and butt can create a more full-bodied, blended orgasm. While wearing the butt plug, pay attention to your other erogenous zones. If you have a penis, try stroking your penis while wearing the plug. If you have a vagina, try using a vibrator on your clit while wearing the plug. You might also try double penetration. 

2. Remove the butt plug as you’re about to climax

Slowly taking the butt plug out when you’re about to orgasm can create an intense sensation as the nerve-endings in and around your anus will be even more activated. 

3. Experiment with weight and material

Butt plugs come in many different forms, including weight and material. Like larger plugs, heavier plugs can also give you a fuller feeling, which can be very arousing. Material can also have a big impact on how a plug feels. For some people, silicon’s softness allows for easier and more comfortable insertion. Harder materials, like steel or glass, might be more of a turn-on for people who’ve been using plugs for a while because of the added pressure on the anus and rectum. You can also experiment with temperature play if you have a glass or stainless steel plug. 

4. Incorporate kink and wear it in public

For some individuals or partners, there’s nothing hotter than the knowledge that you or someone else is wearing a butt plug out in the world. While the act in and of itself can feel really sexy, the pleasure it gives adds another layer.

5. Use it with a whip or flogger

Whips and floggers can bring a sexy medium between ass play and BDSM. If you’re a beginner to using toys like these, opt for softer materials and handles that double as dildos so they’re still pleasurable even if a touch of pain doesn’t end up being your thing.

➡ We recommend: Icicles No 38 Glass Handle Whip

How to use a butt plug with a partner 

While having a partner isn’t required for butt plugs to provide pleasure, wearing one with a partner — or having your partner wear one — gives you plenty of unique ways to enhance the experience. Here are some of our favorite examples.

Incorporate massage

Massage is possibly the most relaxing form of foreplay. When leading up to anal play and butt plugs, massage can be especially helpful because it loosens up the muscles and puts the mind at ease.

Combine with oral sex

Another way to loosen the ass muscles up enough for a butt plug is rimming or doggy-style oral sex. 

Explore dom/sub play

Butt plugs can be a way for partners to play with power dynamics. The person stepping into the dom role can instruct the sub to wear the butt plug somewhere typically nonsexual as a way for them to assert dominance. The sub can send photos to prove submission.

Sex positions to try while wearing a butt plug

Butt plugs are great for a variety of sex positions because they’re hands-free toys — as long as there’s at least one butt available, butt plugs are an option. Here are just a few positions that can be made even better by the use of a butt plug:

Spooning sex

In the spooning sex position, both partners lie down on their sides and face the same direction as the big spoon penetrates the little spoon with a finger, toy, or a penis. If the little spoon has a vagina, the big spoon can penetrate them from behind while the big and little spoon — or just the little spoon — are both wearing butt plugs. If the little spoon has a penis, the big spoon can wear the plug while penetrating the little spoon.

Doggy-style oral sex

This version of oral puts the receiver on hands and knees — and the giver on their knees behind them. Getting into this position allows for full access of both the genitals and the anus, meaning there’s plenty of opportunity to insert a plug while giving head.

69

One partner lies on their back. The other straddles their face and leans over to reach the lying-down person’s genitals. Adjustments can be made (like adding pillows) to more comfortably fit either partner — and either partner can wear a butt plug while going down on the other for double sensations.

The bottom line

Butt plugs are the most commonly used anal toy for good reason — they’re functional, they’re pleasurable, and they’re versatile. Explore our curated catalog of butt toys to find a butt plug, or another type of anal toy, that’s right for you.

Reviewed for Medical Accuracy

Sarah duRivage-Jacobs is a freelance writer and editor who lives in New York City with her creamsicle cat, Jasper. When she's not writing words, she's at a karaoke bar scream-singing "Moana" or binge-watching whatever Netflix releases that week.

Oschool logo

Why shop with us

We support causes you care about, like women’s reproductive rights and accessible sex ed for all.

We donate 5%

When you buy from O.shop, we’ll pledge 5% to support women's health and free sex education.

Hand-picked brands and products for you 

We offer the most popular, best-selling pleasure products to present you with a variety of options for different needs.

Orgasm
Order Form

We want to help you get the orgasm you desire.
Let's get it on
O.school keeps this information totally private and anonymous.  
o shop lowest price